If you grew up in the ’90s as a Pittsburgh Steelers fan, chances are your sports wardrobe wasn’t complete without a Starter jacket, an oversized team sweatshirt, or a snapback hat with an outrageous splash logo. That decade, wedged between the minimalist ’80s and the internet-powered 2000s, was the golden age of sports merch — bold, loud, logo-drenched gear that doubled as fashion statements.
Advertisement
And for many fans today, especially those deep in online collector communities, the love for this aesthetic isn’t just about style. It’s about identity, nostalgia, and in some cases, serious money.
“Between ’88 and ’93 — that was considered the boom,” sports memorabilia appraiser Todd Sawatzky explained of the licensed merch explosion in a recent report. Brands like Logo Athletic and Mitchell & Ness unleashed a wave of apparel marked by massive team crests, neon piping, splashy embroidery, and statement colors.
And interestingly enough, snapbacks from this era — especially rare or short-print runs — remain coveted to date. “I just saw a hat sell for $1,600,” said Casey Pitocchelli recently, who runs the throwback sportswear shop Rare Vntg. “It was an old Philadelphia Phantoms hat. Logo Athletic. It’s really popular.”
So it’s no surprise that when a Redditor on r/steelers posted a photo of a now-rare 1996 Pittsburgh Steelers cap, it sparked an outpouring of love and longing from fans.
The cap featured a deep black base with a Steelers logo in the center, accented by bright yellow thunder-streaks flaring across the crown. It was the kind of design that screamed pure ’90s.
And the icing on the cake was the Redditor captioning their post with a heartfelt memory:
“So I was 10 years old watching this game and I still remember loving this hat… my parents didn’t care for football at all. Had to watch games at a friend’s house… I wish I could’ve gotten one of these hats or they’d bring them back.”
This Steelers cap from the 90s is a piece of art!!! pic.twitter.com/fJ5hDRSjRX
— Burner Boy (@MiraRoadKCChief) June 19, 2025
The nostalgia of the cap, combined with a highly relatable caption, led to the post going viral on the Pittsburgh Steelers subreddit. After all, it struck a chord with fans, helping them reconnect with a moment in time, a childhood memory, or a player they idolized when football still felt like magic.
“I love the ’90s NFL gear. The Starter Jackets were [fire emoji],” hence wrote a Redditor.
“Some of the old merch goes bonky mode. There’s tons of shimmy dimmies I wish they’d blast back for us Pburgh lovas!” added another.
The rest, meanwhile, chimed in with their earliest memories of 90s sports merchandise. “I had all those awesome 90s hats. There was this one, the shark tooth, and the paint splash. Man, those were some cool as* hats!” reminisced a Redditor.
“As my dad used to say, ‘There’s an a** for every seat.’… I remember those hats back in the day. My thoughts on them has not improved at all,” recalled another.
While the Pittsburgh Steelers online store today offers a range of headwear, most modern designs lean toward minimalist aesthetics. So you won’t find this 1996 design — or anything close — available on their official site.
But all hope isn’t lost. Secondary markets like eBay routinely list vintage Steelers hats, with prices ranging anywhere from $10 to $75, depending on condition and rarity.
But the virality of this Reddit post should make teams wonder today if there’s a clear case for them to bring back their retro-style legacy designs. Because even in limited runs, there seems to be potential in this proposition to unlock a fresh revenue stream and tap into the nostalgic core of their fan base.
