Former NFL star Cam Newton stirred the pot (once again) by critiquing San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy, dubbing him a “game manager.” Despite Purdy’s stellar performance, leading his team to Super Bowl LVIII and becoming an NFL MVP finalist, Newton’s assessment was unyielding. He argued that for Purdy to be considered a game-changer, he needed to be the standout player offensively, a status Newton believes Purdy does not fulfill, ranking him 10th in team effectiveness.
Advertisement
Newton’s comments, however, did not go unchallenged. Former cornerback Richard Sherman stepped into the fray with a tweet that brought a broader perspective to the discussion, to defend Purdy. Sherman, known for his outspoken and insightful takes, questioned the fairness of Newton’s judgment.
“I love Cam and have a ton of respect for him, but come on. In your second year in the NFL, you wouldn’t have been the best player on this team, but no one would have put you down because of it. Judge him like you would judge yourself because these categories would have excluded 2nd Year Cam too,” Sherman articulated.
I love Cam and have a ton of respect for him but come on. In your 2nd year in the NFL you wouldn’t have been the best player on this team but no one would have put you down because of it. Judge him like you would judge yourself because these categories would have excluded 2nd… https://t.co/buWdNT1RmB
— Richard Sherman (@RSherman_25) February 2, 2024
Richard Sherman’s got Brock Purdy’s back, and it’s pretty clear why. This whole season, people have been doubting Purdy, calling him just a “game manager” and sidelining all the good stuff he’s done for the team. In his first 17 games as a starter, Purdy hit almost 69.7% of his passes, racking up over 4,200 yards and tossing 34 touchdowns.
That’s not just good; it’s record-setting for the 49ers and puts him up there with the top quarterbacks in the league. Compare that to Cam Newton’s second season: he had 3,869 passing yards and 19 touchdowns, and his team ended with a record of 7-9. It just goes to show that Purdy’s not just playing; he’s making a mark, proving he’s got what it takes to be one of the best.
Brock Purdy Got Vote of Confidence Even Before Stepping Up as Starter
The narrative around Purdy’s journey from doubt to dominance is further enriched by 49ers owner Jed York’s recount of a conversation with coach Kyle Shanahan. Shanahan’s early belief in Purdy’s talent was profound. “I think our third-string quarterback is our best quarterback,” Shanahan asserted, signaling a surprising confidence in Purdy, who was initially behind Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo on the roster.
Shanahan’s prediction was not just a fleeting opinion but a foreshadowing of Purdy’s ascent. York’s reflection on Shanahan’s honesty and foresight underscores the unexpected but well-deserved success that Purdy has achieved.
Richard Sherman’s push for fair judgment, mixed with Purdy’s standout play, really shows how someone can beat the doubts and grow into their potential. It’s a story about giving respect and proving critics wrong.
