mobile app bar

Bobby Witt Jr.’s MVP Case: Can the Royals Star Challenge Yankees Captain Aaron Judge?

Oindrila Chowdhury
Published

Bobby Witt Jr.'s MVP Case: Can the Royals Star Challenge Yankees Captain Aaron Judge?

The competition for the MVP award in MLB is getting intense. Aaron Judge, the Yankees captain has been dominating most of the season. However, KC Royals’ Bobby Witt Jr., who is currently driving the team’s unexpected comeback is now making a bid.

During an episode of Jomboy’s ‘Baseball Today,’ hosts, Chris Rose and Trevor Plouffe dive into whether Bobby Witt Jr. could outshine Aaron Judge for the MVP title this year.

Chris spotlights Witt’s performance and mentions how close he was a single away from hitting for the cycle in a game against the Arizona Diamondbacks – something that put him ahead of Judge in WAR (Wins Above Replacement).

Trevor recognizes Witt’s contributions but points out the difficulty of surpassing Judge. While Witt excels at a premium position like shortstop, Judge leads in statistics such as home runs, RBIs, and batting average. Trevor picked the Yankees captain over the Royals’ standout and stated-

“Judge just leads in everything, man. I just don’t see it happening.” 

Next, Chris points out that Witt’s chances could get better if Kansas City reaches the playoffs by winning the division, as MVP selections tend to lean toward players on successful teams. Moreover, Chris introduces the idea of “voter fatigue” and wonders if voters will become tired of Aaron Judge.

If Judge’s impressive home run numbers like 52 starts to seem not-so-exceptional due to his achievements, it might work in Witt’s favor. Having said that, as the MLB season progresses, the recent MVP poll conducted among 42 MLB.com experts reveals frontrunners in each league while allowing for potential dark horse candidates.

In the American League, Aaron Judge from the Yankees leads with 38 first-place votes due to his performance since May 1, which includes a .372 batting average, 20 home runs, and a 1.388 OPS. Juan Soto follows closely with statistics; he maintains the highest on-base percentage in MLB and has the second-best OPS.

In the American League, Gunnar Henderson from the Orioles, Bobby Witt Jr. from the Royals, and José Ramírez from the Guardians are also among the five players making impacts on their teams through both strong offensive and defensive displays.

Others receiving votes for 2024 AL MVP include:

  • Kyle Tucker (Houston Astros)
  • Rafael Devers (Boston Red Sox)
  • Adley Rutschman (Baltimore Orioles)
  • Salvador Perez (Kansas City Royals)
  • Tarik Skubal (Detroit Tigers)

Shifting focus to the AL Cy Young Award race at this midway point of the MLB season, several pitchers are considered standout candidates for this accolade.

Who’s Leading the American League Cy Young Race?

As per ESPN, the frontrunners for the 2024 American League Cy Young Award in MLB are:

1. Emmanuel Clase – Cleveland Guardians 

2. Craig Kimbrel – Baltimore Orioles 

3. Seth Lugo – Kansas City Royals 

4. Corbin Burnes – Baltimore Orioles 

5. Tarik Skubal- Detroit Tigers

6. Grayson Rodriguez – Baltimore Orioles 

7. Ronel Blanco- Houston Astros 

8. Luis Gil – New York Yankees 

9. Josh Hader- Houston Astros 

10. Logan Gilbert- Seattle Mariners 

Post Edited By:Sampurna Pal

About the author

Oindrila Chowdhury

Oindrila Chowdhury

x-iconfacebook-iconlinkedin-icon

Oindrila is a seasoned sports journalist with over 2 years of experience covering the NFL and MLB. With Sportskeeda and Pinkvilla, she has a combined portfolio of 1000+ published articles under her name. When Oindrila is not glued to covering the news, you might find her deciphering the stock market or keeping up with the next hot fashion trend.

Read more from Oindrila Chowdhury

Share this article