mobile app bar

Ex-F1 Strategist Explains Why Carlos Sainz or Sebastian Vettel Struggled With Strategies at Ferrari

Anirban Aly Mandal
Published

Sebastian Vettel (L) and Carlos Sainz (R)

Ferrari stand out as one of the most iconic and decorated teams in the entire history of Formula 1. However, their recent 17-year-long title drought has been littered with instances where they’ve been called out for their delayed pit stops or miscalculated strategies.

In the past, the likes of Carlos Sainz and Sebastian Vettel have faced the brunt of this, while Charles Leclerc is still vulnerable to such mistakes. Unlike Leclerc, though, Vettel and Sainz were seen taking matters into their own hands when the pit wall made a seemingly incorrect call or delayed making the call to ruin their strategy.

The four-time world champion, in particular, was quite frustrated with Ferrari’s uncertainty regarding the tire strategy. At the 2020 Spanish GP, Vettel was trying to manage his tires while the team wasn’t sure about pitting for a second time. After a sequence of radio calls, the German lashed out at his engineer when he was asked if he could finish the race on the same tires to maximize their result.

While Vettel did score points that afternoon, it wasn’t a good look for the Scuderia. But a team like Ferrari, with endless resources at their disposal, shouldn’t be facing such problems. When this conundrum was placed before former F1 strategist, Bernie Collins on the Red Flags Podcast, the 37-year-old revealed why she felt Ferrari has been lacking on the pit wall.

Referring to the long-legged hierarchy at Ferrari she explained, “When I made a decision [at Aston Martin], very rarely did the management get involved.”

“There’s this ‘oh I don’t want to put my neck on the line because I don’t want to get fired from Ferrari so, I’m gonna ask the guy above me and see what he thinks and then he’s going to ask the guy above him’. I don’t know because I’m not on that pit wall but that’s the impression I get,” she added.

Naturally, for Collins at a small team like Force India (now Aston Martin) she never faced such red-tapism. Therefore, she could make quick decisions on the pit wall and if things went wrong the team could work together to review it and learn.

Has Frederic Vasseur revolutionized the operational side of things at Ferrari?

The constant mistakes on the strategy side of things were one of the biggest reasons why Mattia Binotto got sacked by Ferrari at the end of the 2022 season. And since 2023, Vasseur has attempted to streamline the race operations of the squad.

In fact, under the stewardship of the Frenchman and new strategy head Ravin Jain, the Maranello-based team has seen a massive overhaul of their strategic team. The results are also apparent on the track as the team scored their highest championship total — 652 points — in the last decade.

Former Ferrari engineer, Rob Smedley credited Vasseur for creating an environment within the team that fostered these changes. At a team like Ferrari where the stakes are high, the Frenchman has instilled a sort of calming presence.

“He is very intelligent, but he is also very disarming, and I think that is a good quality to have in a top manager in a pressure cooker environment like that,” explained Smedley.

Post Edited By:Aishwary Gaonkar

About the author

Anirban Aly Mandal

Anirban Aly Mandal

linkedin-icon

Anirban Aly Mandal is an F1 writer at The SportsRush, with over 1000 articles under his belt, Anirban's love for F1 started when he discovered a copy of F1 2014 on his computer. With over half a decade's worth of time spent religiously following the sport, he’s dived deep into the world of motorsports. However, Anirban's expertise goes beyond just writing - he has also written several academic papers focused on the domain of motorsports and the law. His passion for the sport is so immense that he aspires to work as a legal advisor in the most prestigious racing series in the world someday. When it comes to Formula 1, Anirban finds great pleasure in re-watching classic races and idolizes the likes of Ayrton Senna, Nigel Mansell, and Sebastian Vettel. His top picks include Brazil '91, Silverstone '92, and Germany '19. Outside of the sport, Anirban is an avid sim racer, often found racing on titles like Assetto Corsa, F1 22, and Automobilista. Apart from his interests in gaming, Anirban has a keen interest in philosophy, literature and music.

Share this article