Kyle Petty Gives Damning Verdict on “Perennial Pretender” Chase Elliott Amid NASCAR Struggles

“What happened to the day when he (Chase Elliott) could win on every track?” As harsh as it sounds, Kyle Petty is asking this very question to the driver of the No.9 Hendrick Motorsports Chevrolet: Chase Elliott.

The 2020 NASCAR Cup Series champion was once regarded as the best in the sport. His expertise on road-course races was unquestionable. But what set him apart was his ability to win on other types of tracks that NASCAR offers.

However, since the Next Gen car was introduced in 2022, Elliott has been somewhat lost in the grand scheme of things.

Fourteen races in, Elliott remains winless despite consistently scoring stage points and solid finishes. While P5 in the regular season standings might paint a rosy picture, Kyle Petty does not necessarily align with that train of thought.

Petty compared Elliott’s performance to his teammates, namely Kyle Larson and William Byron, who seemed to be the leading duo for HMS last year, and this season as well. He questioned, “Byron is putting that thing in the top five every single week, leading laps, dominating races.

“And we look at the #5 (Larson) car yesterday (Nashville), horrendous performance in the first segment, was within 15-20 feet of getting lapped, and they work, and he gets a top 10 out of it. The whole time he’s doing this, the #9 car is hovering around 17th, 18th, 19th.”

Petty terms Elliott the ‘perennial pretender’

Petty also touched on how HMS, as an organization, is capable of providing its drivers with race-winning cars. However, Elliot’s and Alex Bowman’s performance so far has been discouraging. Petty is not backing either to make a deep run in the playoffs this year.

Petty even went as far as to question one of GoPRNLive co-hosts’ label for Elliott. While the No. 9 was the ‘perennial contender’ for a few, Petty had other ideas. “I took a double-take because I thought you said a perennial pretender.”

Roasting Cup Series drivers aside, Petty does put forward a valid point. Ever since the seventh generation ‘Next Gen’ car’s debut, and Elliott’s ski accident, the former champion has not looked the same.

Elliott himself did not lay all his eggs in the ‘win-and-you’re-in’ basket. He said, “I want to be in the group of people of how many playoff points do you have, not just barely getting in.”

How that works out for him and his No. 9 crew in 2025 remains to be seen.