mobile app bar

Position Battles – NL West

Elliott Price
Published

Position Battles - NL West

The Dodgers are loaded, the D’Backs retooled, the Padres were quiet, the Giants both added and lost and the Rockies still suck.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Barring an injury the D’Backs starting eight and DH are in place, that means Pavin Smith wins the empty spot vacated by Joc Peterson’s departure. It also means young hitters Adrian Del Castillo (catcher) and Jordan Lawlar (shorstop) will either search for at bats or return to the minors.

The questions are in the pitching department. If  Merrill Kelly, Brandon Pfaadt and Edouardo Rodriguez are locked in at 3-4-5 where does that leave Jordan Montgomery ($25 million for 2025)?

Position Battles - NL West
Sep 17, 2024; Denver, Co, USA; Diamondbacks pitcher Jordan Montgomery leaves the mound at Coors Field. Mandatory Credit: Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images

Justin Martinez inherited the closer role when Paul Sewald fell apart. Keeping it means no signing of a free agent of which there are still many capable ones available or AJ Puk grabbing it in the spring.

Colorado Rockies

So many problems for this team. Everybody else in the division is much much better mostly because they are really good to great and the Rockies are not.

Brendan Rodgers is gone. Newcomers Thairo Estrada and Kyle Farmer will see time at second.

Last outfield spot goes to Jordan Beck, Sam Hilliard or maybe Hunter Goodman.

With Jacob Stallings, the incumbent behind the plate and Austin Nola invited to camp, there’s an opening for twenty-three year old Drew Romo.

Position Battles - NL West
Mar 3, 2024; Phoenix, Az, USA; Rockies catcher Drew Romo during spring training at Camelback Ranch-Glendale. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

In the rotation, first rounder Chase Dollander challenges for a spot. The closer role is wide open, Victor Vodnik, Seth Halvorsen, Justin Lawrence and Tyler Kinley all with a shot.

Los Angeles Dodgers

It’s tough being a prospect in the Dodgers system. Gavin Lux was finally shown the door with a trade to Cincinnati. With both Teoscar Hernández and Tommy Edman staying put, Andy Pages will be fighting for playing time.

There also appears to be no room for top prospect Dalton Rushing even though he’s useful both behind the plate and in the outfield.

Even with an expected six man rotation, there are so many arms here and now with the Sasaki signing that’s a lot of talent for spot six. Yamamoto, Snell, Glasnow, Ohtani and Sasaki certainly claiming the first five spots.

So let’s see. There’s Landon Knack, Tony Gonsolin,Dustin May and Bobby Miller. Will there still be room for a Clayton Kershaw return?

Michael Kopech grabbed the closer’s role from Evan Phillips but you couldn’t tell me Blake Treinen couldn’t handle it or even Alex Vesia.

San Diego Padres

The Padres just don’t seem set. There are rumours about a potential Luis Arráez trade. Jurickson Profar’s departure opens left field and who will DH?

Fangraphs roster-resource has Tirso Arnelos in left and Eguy Rosario at DH.  Sure, why not. There’s still plenty of time before opening day.

The four/five rotation slots are open – Randy Vasquez and Matt Waldron tentatively holding those spots. Reliever Adrian Morejon will be given a shot

Position Battles - NL West
Sep 20, 2024; San Diego, Ca, USA; Padres pitcher Adrian Morejon at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Orlando Ramirez-Imagn Images

Robert Suarez is the closer despite a downturn at season’s end. Like Arráez and starter Dylan Cease there’s been noise of a possible trade.

San Francisco Giants

Jung Hoo Lee returns from injury to claim center. Willie Adames signing moves Tyler Fitzgerald to second. Lamonte Wade jr’s at first but keep an eye on power hitting prospect Bryce Eldridge.

With the addition of Justin Verlander, the rotation appears full. Ryan Walker was effective after grabbing the closer’s role from Camilo Doval who’s still around.

About the author

Elliott Price

Elliott Price

x-icon

Elliott spent more than 40 years in sports broadcasting. He hosted sports morning shows in both Montreal and Toronto. Elliott handled play by play duties in a multitude of sports. Most notably as the voice of the Montreal Expos. Also CFL football, NHL hockey, OHL and QMJHL junior hockey, boxing, soccer, swimming and more. He currently is senior baseball writer for 'The Sports Rush'

Share this article