“The Steelers Are Back In Business”: Aaron Rodgers, Patrick Mahomes Comparison Makes Fans Hopeful For Pittsburgh

Suresh Menon | 08/06/2025
Aaron Rodgers, Patrick Mahomes

Aaron Rodgers is undeniably one of the greatest quarterbacks to have graced the National Football League. Be it his pure passing ability or football IQ, Rodgers, in his time with Green Bay, has consistently redefined what was possible from the pocket. But A-Rod enters the twilight of his career.

At 41, and fresh off a disastrous 2-year stint with the Jets that saw him marred with injuries and off-field drama, the focus around the quarterback has now shifted from what he can do to how long he can do it. So naturally, his latest $19.5 million, one-year deal with the Pittsburgh Steelers is being met with cautious optimism.

While narratives, opinions and form remain transient in nature, what is permanent is statistical data. For numbers never lie, and according to them, Aaron Rodgers still belongs to the crème de la crème in the NFL — a claim that can be proved when one compares the veteran quarterback to Patrick Mahomes.

The Steelers quarterback’s last season in New York saw him throw 28 touchdown passes—more than Patrick Mahomes, who finished with 26. This stat alone sparked immediate comparisons online. But it goes even deeper.

In terms of career accolades, the Chiefs star has three Super Bowl titles to Rodgers’ one, two All-Pro selections to Rodgers’ four, and a career win-loss record of 89-23 versus Rodgers’ 153-87-1. But when it comes to stats that truly reveal the quality of a quarterback, it is a neck-and-neck battle.

While A-Rod (102.6) slightly edges Mahomes (102.1) in QBR, the 29-year-old holds a narrow lead at 66.6%, compared to Rodgers’ 65.1% in completion percentage. And MVPs? Rodgers has four to Mahomes’ two. All this, despite Aaron Rodgers being 12 years older than him.

It’s this statistical proximity that gives Steelers fans a reason to hope. After all, Aaron Rodgers didn’t just join any team. He has signed with a Pittsburgh franchise that hasn’t had a true offensive identity since Ben Roethlisberger’s final years.

For a franchise that’s been starved for so long, their latest quarterback’s statistical superiority has given the fans something to look forward to.

“If the Steelers O-line holds up, then you can pretty much say that Steelers are back in business,” wrote a fan. “Aaron Rodgers also did this with the 2nd worst run game in the league,” raved another.

One fan, meanwhile, argued that stats only provide half the picture because Broncos rookie Bo Nix arguably had a better statistical season than both the quarterbacks in question.

“What’s your point? Bo Nix had more then both of them yet we all know he not Mahomes level at this point in career,” argued the fan.

The rest believed what truly matters is the result. “A Rod and his team won like 4 games, meanwhile Patty made another SB appearance,” wrote an “X” user.

It’s true that the soon-to-be 42-year-old Aaron Rodgers’ physical mobility is not what it once was. However, the Steelers have given him all the tools necessary with promising offensive linemen like Broderick Jones, Troy Fautanu, and Isaac Seumalo, while surrounding him with weapons like DK Metcalf, Calvin Austin III, and Pat Freiermuth.

It’s safe to say Mike Tomlin & Co. may really be back in business.

Post Edited By: Karthik Raman
Aaron Rodgers Kansas City Chiefs Patrick Mahomes Pittsburgh Steelers

About the author

Suresh Menon

Suresh Menon is an NFL writer at The SportsRush with over 700 articles to his name. Early in his childhood, Suresh grew up admiring the famed BBC of Juventus making the Italian club his favorite. His love for soccer however soon translated to American football when he came across a Super Bowl performance from his Favourite Bruno Mars. Tom Brady’s performance in the finals left an imprint on him and since then, he has been a die hard Brady fan. Thus his love for the sport combined with his flair for communication is the reason why he decided to pursue sports journalism at The SportsRush. Beyond football, in his free time, he is a podcast host and likes spending time solving the Rubik’s cube.

Don’t miss these