Exclusive: O.J. McDuffie Tells “Outspoken” Tyreek Hill to “Show Up Every Sunday” for the Miami Dolphins

Tyreek Hill is a born competitor, driven by excellence and unafraid to wear his emotions on his sleeve. That fiery passion was on full display when the Miami Dolphins missed the playoffs last season. It was the first time in his career that he didn’t play postseason football, and he didn’t take it well.

In the heat of the moment, the Cheetah said he was “opening a door” and wanted to leave Miami. His frustration was so intense that he said he wanted to leave the place he had previously called the best stop of his career. Soon after, the All-Pro wideout admitted he could have handled the situation more maturely.

Hill reiterated his commitment to the Dolphins, saying he wants to stay, win with this team, and be part of something special. He also emphasized how much his kids love living in Miami. The Dolphins responded by restructuring his deal with an improved extension. Former Dolphins wide receiver O.J. McDuffie shared his thoughts on Hill’s emotional outburst in an exclusive interview with The SportsRush. 

While McDuffie appreciated that Hill spoke his mind, he also emphasized that there’s a line between passion and professionalism. It’s one thing to feel frustrated, but it’s another to publicly express it during games or lash out at teammates on live TV.

“I don’t mind him speaking his mind, but you know what, when you do that, you have to go out there and show up every Sunday, Monday, Thursday. Whatever day we are playing, you’ve got to be the one that goes out there and puts up the numbers we expect you to put up,” said McDuffie.

“Put up effort. We expect you to put out and not take yourself out of the football games late when we are losing, not going off on your teammates,” added the former WR, who played his entire NFL career with the Dolphins (from 1993 to 2001).

McDuffie pointed to quarterback Tua Tagovailoa as a model of emotional control — someone who remains composed regardless of the moment. He wants Hill to be like his QB and handle his emotions more productively, backing up his words with consistent effort and dominant performances.

pic.twitter.com/HgLSgJ5BwB

— Josh McCaffrey (@JoshMcCaff911) July 27, 2025

Hill has changed his tone after preseason training kicked off. He even encouraged Jalen Ramsey to stay in Miami and be part of something special, possibly making history next season by helping the Dolphins finally win a playoff game for their fans and themselves.

However, the odds are stacked against them. Oddsmakers project just 8.5 wins for Miami, giving them +190 odds to make the postseason, the 10th lowest in the NFL. If they fall short again, it likely won’t be long before Hill expresses his frustration and potentially follows Ramsey by seeking a trade.

At this stage of his career, Hill wants to compete consistently and win another Super Bowl. While money may be the only thing keeping him in Miami for now, another team would have no problem matching his price tag if he hits the market. So, the Dolphins must reach the playoffs next season, or risk losing their best player.