Earlier this season, Los Angeles Chargers fans took issue with Ryan Fitzpatrick’s analysis of Justin Herbert. They also had problems with Dan Pizzuta’s placement of Herbert in his personal QB Power Rankings. Unfortunately for those critics, Fitzpatrick and Pizzuta have gotten the last laugh.
Advertisement
Herbert flopped in Saturday’s wild-card playoff game against the Houston Texans. The fifth-year pro completed a paltry 43.8% (14/32) of his passes for 242 yards in the Chargers’ 32-12 loss. Herbert tossed four interceptions in the contest after throwing just three across 17 regular season appearances.
Texans pick off Justin Herbert FOR THE FOURTH TIME TODAY
Reminder: He only threw 3 ALL SEASON pic.twitter.com/0ioN7gR71p
— NFL on CBS (@NFLonCBS) January 12, 2025
Los Angeles’ franchise quarterback looked overwhelmed all afternoon. Nearly one-third of his yards (86) came on an incredible touchdown grab by rookie wide receiver Ladd McConkey. Producing such a brutal stat line after ending the regular season in tremendous fashion upset Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy, who called Herbert a “dysfunctional robot” on Twitter/X.
I couldn’t wait for the #shredline Justin Herbert SUCKS pic.twitter.com/LZyoQtPi1R
— Dave Portnoy (@stoolpresidente) January 12, 2025
Herbert also absorbed four sacks in Houston’s dominant defensive showing. Portnoy’s strong feelings about Herbert stem from a bet he made, but some fans in his comment section shared his thoughts. Others defended Herbert, stating two of his interceptions were not his fault.
Yeah he’s overrated hard
— Jeff Moll (@bigjeffm) January 12, 2025
Can’t believe people think he’s better than burrow.
— CMAC (@mackiephresh17) January 12, 2025
You’re just wrong Dave
— Jimmy Bisharat (@athletesadvisor) January 12, 2025
Bro his entire WR corps and TEs dropped balls through their hands all day, 1st pick was his fault sure the last 2 nah.
He had 3 INTs all year lmao
— InfinDimensions (@InfinDimensions) January 12, 2025
That 3rd pick wasn’t Herbert’s fault but he sucks today.
— Andy froemel (@FroemelAndy) January 12, 2025
McConkey and tight end Will Dissly had passes go through their hands on two of Herbert’s interceptions. He may not be directly responsible for those, but he still would have completed only half his attempts (16/32) if they were caught. No matter how you slice things, he didn’t play well. His first interception exemplifies the types of bad decisions he made throughout the game.
Justin Herbert with an absolutely AWFUL INTERCEPTION… is this kid ever gonna prove himself or what???
pic.twitter.com/AFjJQs7e6G— John Frascella (Football) (@NFLFrascella) January 11, 2025
Despite today’s tough showing, Herbert enjoyed a successful first year with Jim Harbaugh. The duo should remain in the playoff hunt next season. If they make it again, the Chargers will hope Herbert avoids repeating this performance.